Introduction:
A biotechnological invention could normally consist of merchandise, compositions and tactics, a body of microorganisms as bacteria and fungi, part of microorganisms, plasmids and allied products as antibiotics and enzymes derived from recombinant DNA, antigens, monoclonal antibodies, hybridoma, synthetic organs, and novel microorganisms received because of discovery.
The world intellectual belongings enterprise (WIPO) defines biotechnology as any era using residing entities, specifically animals, plants, or microorganisms, or inflicting a trade in them. Biotechnology has a first-rate impact and ability in the discipline of agricultural strategies, plant types of improvement, pharmaceutical troubles, health, and surroundings widely recognized as one of the frontier technologies and witnessed a new explosion in the vicinity of the latest technology in this location drawing the eye of the IPRs claims throughout the globe. Biotechnology is a brand-new place that has grown to be the subject to rely upon world attention regarding its patentability, especially with appreciation to genetically changed organisms.
Biotechnology patents have come to be an incredibly hot topic through the years, gaining high profiles in some instances. Due to the sensitive and complicated nature of this precise area of look at, the patenting method is greater than in different fields.
History
Inventors have been filing packages for biotechnological patents for over one hundred years. On 29 July 1873, microbiologist Louis Pasteur patented his improved yeast-making method on the French Patent workplace. Commercial firms and companies additionally sought to patent biotechnological approaches, with BASF patenting alizarin (a pink dye that was utilized in fabric manufacturing) in 1869.
In recent years, researchers have succeeded in better knowledge of the functioning of the human frame and its immune system. Biotechnology has already supplied life-saving medicines along with human insulin, erythropoietin, and so on., and it seems to promise treatment plans for conditions that presently seemed untreatable.
In agriculture, biotechnology is used to modify the physiology of plants to introducing specific applicable capabilities, inclusive of resistance to sickness and herbicides, or reaching higher yields.
Biological Patenting
Biotechnology has several subfields, and each sub-area has traits that might be specific from others that the broad set of standard regulations cannot be taken into consideration for the field of biotechnology as an entire. For instance, genomics and tissue culture, both are extraordinary and precise in characteristics, programs, processes, and merchandise, and so forth. The following are several the various sub-fields that fall underneath the scope of biotechnology:
1.Bioprocessing technology:
It is a technique that tends to supply fabric associated with biotechnology, which includes genetically engineered microbial strain for industrial functions.
2. Hybridoma and Monoclonal Antibody technology:
Through this approach, equal antibodies are created in a large quantity. It’s also referred to as Monoclonal Antibodies.
3. Cell culture:
It’s far a technique in which cells are made to be grown under a few controlled conditions outdoor in their natural environment.
4. Cloning:
It’s far a system in which genetically same individuals of an organism are produced both certainly and in a synthetic way.
5. Genomics and Proteomics:
These fields are related closely to each other. The distinction among each is that genomics is the examiner of the set of genes inside the genome of cellular and proteomics is the examiner of the proteins produced by the cells.
6. DNA Fingerprinting:
It is also called DNA typing, DNA profiling, genotyping or identification testing, genetic fingerprinting, method of keeping apart and figuring out variable elements in the base-pair sequence of DNA.
“Patent is a monopoly right conferred via the Patent workplace on an inventor to make the most of his invention for a constrained time. At the same time as an invention manner, a brand-new product or system regarding a resourceful step and business application.”
Patents are a part of intellectual property law that works to help protect the revolutionary methods across all one-of-a-kind fields. A patent is posted for the public’s inspection, so often patents are used in research tasks. Now and again people or agencies should buy rights to a patent if they need to apply or produce the protected invention. If a person invents a unique product or technique, they could advantage a sort of monopoly right over that invention to prevent others from making or using it without their permission. This creates incentive and reward for ingenuity. If a patent is granted, the info of the invention will be disclosed to the public, but it’s going to additionally be blanketed from patent infringement.
Biotechnology patents have come to be an incredibly hot topic through the years, gaining high profiles in some instances. Due to the sensitive and complicated nature of this precise area of taking a look at, the patenting method is greater than in different fields. Ascertain organizations attempt to discourage biotechnology patents, others argue that they may be a critical part of the thriving economy and intellectual advancements. unique countries range on their laws concerning the patenting of biotechnology.
Types of Biotechnology Patents
In almost every discipline of studies, there are primary varieties of patents:
1.Product patents.
It is an extraordinary property given to the authentic inventor of a product. Because of this, no different manufacturer can provide an equal product thru the same or another procedure. The implication is that there’ll not be a competitor for the producer as it’s for the product that’s patented.
2.Process patents.
Under a process patent, the patent is granted for a particular production process, and not for the product itself. Any other person can produce the same product via a few other processes, editing the diverse parameters.
Laws regarding Biological Patenting in India
According to Article 27(3) of the TRIP settlement, individuals must allow patenting of microorganisms, micro-organic and non-organic approaches for the production of flowers and animals. This provision initiates toward patenting of lifestyle forms as microorganisms are greatly beneficial in diverse elements of agriculture, fitness, and the environment. numerous strategies and product development can be approached through a biotech course.
The sections of the Patents Act, 1970 (Act) which can be emphasized for the examination of programs associated with Biotechnology Patents in India and associated fields are as follows:
Section 2 (1) (j) of the Act, wherein the provisions are associated with novelty, ingenious step & business applicability of merchandise or tactics.
Section 3 (b) of the Act, in which the provisions are associated with innovations contrary to morality, or which cause critical prejudice to human, animal, or plant life or health or surroundings.
Section 3 (c) of the Act, in which the provisions are related to the discovery of any dwelling thing or non-residing substance going on in nature.
Section 3 (d) of the Act, wherein the provisions are associated with Mere discovery of a new form of a recognized substance which does no longer bring about enhancement of regarded efficacy or mere discovery of any new belongings or new use for a recognized substance.
Section 3 (e) of the Act, in which the provisions are related to Mere admixture ensuing most effectiveness inside the aggregation of the houses.
Section 3 (h) of the Act, wherein the provisions are associated with the technique of agriculture and horticulture.
Section 3 (i) of the act, wherein the provisions are associated with the approach of remedy and analysis.
Section 3 (j) of the Act, in which the provisions are associated with plant life and animals incomplete or any part thereof aside from micro-organisms, but along with seeds, varieties, and species, and organic tactics.
Section 3 (k) of the Act, wherein the provisions are associated with computer programs consistent with se and algorithms, mathematical methods.
Section 3 (p) of the Act, wherein the provisions are related to inventions that can be in impact traditional know-how.
Section 10 (4) of the Act, an applicant must deposit the biological material mentioned within the specification if it is unavailable to the public and cannot be defined effectively as in keeping with the provisions of the act. The material should be deposited with a worldwide depository authority below the Budapest Treaty.
Section 10 (5) of the Act, in which the provisions are associated with the team spirit of invention and readability, succinctness, and aid of the claims.
Different Perspective of Patent Law Around the World
- US
The united states have followed the most liberal technique within the areas of patents regarding biotechnology it is admissible to patent animals and plant types in the US inside the US, the Patent Act does now not contain any exclusionary provisions and has tested to be the USA with the most liberal method toward patenting innovations inside the field of biotechnology. the USA considers an invention to be patentable if it possesses a ‘system’ and ‘the machine’. inside the USA, one of the maximum relevant exclusions for the biotechnological innovations is ‘laws of Nature’ exclusion. The stated exclusion way that anything that exists or is ‘manufactured from nature’ isn’t patentable.
The questionability approximately ‘patentable subject count number in the united states of America’ was first laid down in Funk Bros. Seed Co. v. Kalo Innoculant Co. The said case worried about whether micro-organisms are patentable. The court held that mere aggregation of species isn’t an invention underneath the patent regime. considering that there was no production of the latest micro-organism which was not invented before and additionally there was no trade within the species of micro-organism.
To be able to get a patent in the US, an invention must fulfill the following necessities.
1.Patentable subject matter: The primary and the most fundamental requirement for patentability is that the discovery needs to fall within the scope of patentable situation matter as described by the patent statute. The scope and volume of patentable difficulty to be counted is overly broad and open in the US. only laws of herbal global, big phenomena, conceptual and summary ideas fall outside the volume of patentable concern cloth.
2.Utility: Phase one zero one of the America patent Act gives that an invention or discovery must be beneficial if you want to be eligible for a patent supply. Usefulness is a completely subjective inquiry and isn’t always taken into consideration strictly through the USPTO while handling biotech inventions to fulfill this requirement, an invention must have some sensible application within the shape of instant benefit to the public.
3.Novelty: Novelty method originality or innovation. An invention categorized to be patentable must be new in the mild of the prior art seek.
4.Non-obviousness: An invention so that you can be patentable should be non-obvious within the mild of the earlier art. The discovery could not be patentable if the variations between the problem remember sought to be patented and the prior art is such that in the subject count as an entire could have been apparent at the time the discovery turned into made to someone having ordinary ability inside the art to which stated subject remember pertains.
Underneath US patent regulation, DNA sequences are taken into consideration chemicals utilizing US Patent workplace and are patentable as compositions of depending. Thus, the US provides patents on all plants of a specific species into which a particular new gene is inserted via a biotechnological manner. In this manner, a gene can be patented together with prison claims over the remoted gene and DNA sequences, the genetic engineering equipment that uses the sequences, and over the flora derived from those tools.
- India
In India any product or manner comes in the patentable subject depending on no matter generation. The Patent Act also presents a long list of exclusions for granting a patent which also includes biotechnology inventions. Exclusions consisting of any discovery of dwelling matters which have been passed off in nature are not taken into consideration to be a patentable problem dependent in India. Prohibited biotechnology subjects, also, include plants and animals incomplete or any element thereof which includes seeds, types, species, and essentially organic methods for manufacturing or propagation of plant life and animals. however, the patent is granted to micro-organisms or microbiological techniques. Also, any genetically modified multicellular organisms which besides consists of flora, animals, and human beings are exclusions under the Patent Act.
Indian Patent Act, 1970, presents a simple definition of the term, ‘invention’ in section 2(1) (j) of the Act that “Invention means a brand-new product or technique concerning an ingenious step which can industrial application”. The criteria for patentability of an invention are novelty, non-obviousness, and business software or utility.
1.Novelty, as the first essential standards mean that the invention ought to be new and it must be unique from ‘earlier art’. ‘earlier art’ shows that it needs to not have been posted anywhere within the world or in the public area before the date of filing of patent software.
2.An inventive step or non-obviousness means that an invention ought to now not be obvious to a person skilled in the art. a character professional in art is presumed to a normal practitioner privy to what became commonplace well-known expertise within the artwork.
3. For fulfilling the requirement of utility, an invention ought to be used in at least one field of hobby and it shall also be reproduced with comparable functions whilst determined essentially. The Patent Act has now not in particular stated something concerning the applicability of biotechnology, therefore well-known business applicability features are carried out for biotechnology innovations. Furthermore, the recommendations concerning analyzing biotechnology innovations within the manual of Patent exercise sincerely mention that gene sequences and DNA sequences, the functions of which aren’t disclosed do now not fulfill the utility requirement.
Accordingly, for an invention to be patentable, the Indian patent regulation calls for the invention to be new, to have an imaginative step (non-apparent), and to be industrially applicable (software). The question of whether the materials such as microorganisms or other organic substances, which might be found in nature, can be handled as new, is to be determined through making use of the above criteria. The necessities of the imaginative step represent one of the maximum complicated questions inside the field of biotechnology.
- Australia
For an Australian patent to be eligible for a patent time extension, the claims of the patent should contain both a pharmaceutical substance according to use or the only one produced by a system involving the use of recombinant DNA. A pharmaceutical substance is described as a compound, an active metabolite, a composition, or a combination of substances.
Necessities for acquiring PTE: To consist of pharmaceutical substance inside the Australian sign-in of therapeutic goods, at the least 5 years between the filing of patent application and date of first marketing approval, software to be made inside 6 months of a provider of patent and from first regulatory approval date. consequently, the most length of the patent term extension is 5 years.
- Japan
In Japan, the patent term extension for five years is to be had for prescribed drugs and agrochemicals. but Japan lacks provision for any additional extension length (e.g., 6-month pediatric extension inside the ECU.). An application for an extension of the term should be filed within 3 months of the first regulatory approval of the product. extensively, in Japan subsequent popularity of the same lively aspect for a second indication may also function as a foundation for a further extension.
Japan is the simplest country that has a minimal time of patent time extension i.e., 2 years, and a request for extension of the period has been placed forth by the Japan Pharmaceutical industry association to abrogate the two years. The software for PTE cannot be filed with the Patent office every time after 6 months before the expiration of patent rights in Japan.
- Russia
The patent term extension is relevant to the completion of the Confederation of Russia. The patent term extension procedure was first added in Russia in 2003. In accordance with Russian rules, which regulated the patent period extension system until 2015, a patent directed at a medicine, pesticide, or agrochemical became extended in recognition of the claims protecting the product. In October 2014 amendments were made to the Civil Code, in which the amendments added the procedure of grant of a supplementary patent restrained to the advertised product. New patent period extension rules have been positioned into force on 8 January 2016. but the usual term of patent term extension is 5 years.
- Ukraine
The period of a patent associated with drugs – for protecting humans, animals, and plants, can be extended on the request of the owner for a duration now not more than 5 years. Ukraine presents a possibility to extend the period for a medicinal /agrochemical product patent. In December 2018, the cabinet authorized a draft law to carry Ukrainian IP law in step with the European-Ukraine association agreement. underneath the draft regulation, patent safety will not be granted to diagnostic, therapeutic, and surgical strategies for treating human beings or animals and to newer forms of recognized medicinal products. Also, the regulation held that the length of supplementary safety should be the same as the length among the application date and the date of the first authorization using a position authority, not exceeding a complete of five years.
- Taiwan
The patent term extension practice was delivered in 1994 through Patent Act Amendments (PAAs). only the 2011 PAAs involve the patent period extension practice. A term extension can be sought for a pharmaceutical or an agrochemical-associated patent under the situation that the first market acclaim for practising said patent isn’t always secured until two years after the patent booklet (“-12 months drawback”). The two-year hindrance turned into removal via the 2011 Patent Act Amendments.
Present scenario
Present-day biotechnological advances have posed new challenges before the existing patent laws of countries as biotechnological innovations fluctuate markedly from chemical and mechanical inventions which have been the traditional subject remembered by patents. With the development of human genomics and the success of the Human Genome venture, the gene becomes more important due to its informational content as opposed to its fabric qualities (bodily attributes). A patent is a topic overall involved with questions inside a jurisdiction. Even though the adoption and ratification of change-related aspects of highbrow property rights (journeys) have added a unified person to patent legal guidelines of member countries of the world change organization (WTO) to a positive quantity, those countries have followed exceptional methods regarding biotechnology patents in song with their national regulations. The United States being a pioneer in biotechnology research exerts incredible impact upon different international locations; the ECU Union reflects the unified technique of different member states in a politically various system; Canada makes a distinction among patenting of higher lifestyles paperwork and lower existence bureaucracy and India represents the issues of growing countries.
Cases
1.Funk Bros. Seed Co. v. Kalo Innoculant Co. inside the said case concerned an issue approximately whether micro-organisms are patentable. The court held that mere aggregation of species isn’t always an invention beneath the patent regime. Considering that there was no production of the latest micro-organism which changed into not invented before and additionally there was no alternative within the species of bacteria.
2.‘Amgen v. Chugai’ patent changed into no longer given for DNA sequences encoding erythropoietin (additionally referred to as ‘EPO’) and the granting patent to them become also held invalid while in comparison to non-obviousness step and along with other claims.
3.In the case of Diamond v Anand Chakrabarty, a biochemist at well-known electric powered (GE) advanced a genetically modified organism that had the functionality to decompose crude oil. First, the Patent application of the inventor turned into rejection. but later, a similar enchantment turned into made which and the Patent turned into granted by using the court to the inventor with an order stating that the declaration of the inventor isn’t to a hitherto unknown natural phenomenon, but a non-evidently happening composition or manufacture of count-a fabricated from human inventiveness.
Conclusion
The international legal system pertaining to the patent regime needs to be redefined with an affiliation of ongoing biotechnological development in developing nations. In the present situation, biotechnology has the capability to serve the public in numerous methods by way of offering remarkable blessings to health, food, remedy, and surroundings. The approach, whilst managing biotechnology needs to be realistic and efficient. The patent is the maximum feasible device for patent protection. The patent system provides top-of-the-line protection by using encouraging inventors to pay attention to the view of business programs additionally.
The necessities regarding granting a patent to biotechnology innovations in India, Europe, and the United States are otherwise implemented when compared to different inventions where a patent is granted. It’s pertinent to notice that ‘Morality’ performs a crucial function in determining the patentability of biotechnology innovations. Moreover, the requirements have usually been taken into consideration higher in Europe and India whilst as compared to the USA.
Reference:
1. G J Annas, “The Man on the Moon, Immortality and Other Millennal Myths: The Prospects and Perils of Human Genetic Engineering” (2000) 49 Emory Law Journal 753
2. Thomson, The Grey Penumbra of Interpretation Surrounding the Obvious Test for Biotech Patents, European Intellectual Property Review, EIPR 1996, 18(2), 90-96
3. Indian Patent office (http://www.ipindia.nic.in/)
0 Comments