Is Porn Crime in India?

Introduction:

In India, pornography is available in print magazines, but it is mainly used while using the Internet. The pornography is increasing day by day, as the increase in modern technologies like the use of smartphones etc. Despite increasing these access, and more use of pornography remain muted and a taboo in many regions in India.

Publishing in public and transferring/sending pornographic material is illegal in India. In the world, India is the 3rd most porn-watching country. The Average visit to the website for traffic originating from India is 9 min and 30 sec, and the world average is of about 9 min and 20 seconds. [1]

But, at home watching porn is not illegal in India. Communication i.e. sending a text, photo, video or anything obscene or containing sexually explicit act (unless for bona fide purpose like sex education) is also illegal in India.

There are 2 types of pornography– Softcore and Hardcore, where the pornography work is referred to as the hardcore content and the softcore pornography consists of nudity or partial nudity in sexual situations. Both types of pornography basically involved nudity. The print media and the Internet have found by the studies that these are also a form of media to communicate, but In India Internet is more accessible than print media. In India, cultural taboos and legal issue are the two main desirable ways to view pornography through Internet means.

Ther are up to 30-70% total traffic from porn websites which are become more popular in India. Even National Capital Delhi has been recorded the total viewership of porn web sites is nearly about 40% of all traffic. In India, online Erotic comics have been becoming more popular as the internet becomes more readily available to the common citizen.

Essentials Definitions:

In a Duke journal– definition focused more clearly on the abuse of women..

Sunstein defines- it has four elements i.e sexual explicities, depictions of women as enjoying or deserving abuse, the purpose of arousal and the effect of arousal.

The main essentials for pornography are the excess use of the internet and giving phones to teenage students. The students are not aware regarding the sex education, the youth didn’t aware about the illegal things, happening in their smartphones, and the adds which comes while surfing on internet is the main essential thing which harms the mind set up of the youth.

Legislation

There are many legal point of views, in which the Judicial decisions come under certain ways in which Porn is illegal in India. But as our law stop the using of pornography material in public while it isn’t illegal while watching pornography in privately.

All that the law prohibits its:- Production, distribution, transmission, publication.

1. Section 67B  of IT Act 2000– As section 67 is related to cyber pornography, while section 67B says that, Child pornography is illegal and prohibited strictly across India. Basically this sections implies the punishment for pornographic material depicting children in sexual acts etc..in electronic form.
2. Punishment for publishing or transmitting obscene material in electronic form
3. Imprisonment for 3years or fine of 5,00,000.
4. For subsequent conviction imprisonment for 5years and with 10,00,000 rupees fine.
5. Section 292, 293 of Indian Penal Code (IPC) 1860—The selling and distributing of pornographic material is illegal in India. Even manufacturing and publishing..

Section 292-293 were amended by Act XXXVI of 1969. Clause(1) of the section explains specifically the connotation of the expression obscenity. Clause(2) of the section punishes a person who sells or in any manner conveys publicity the obscene books or any other material of the same effect

• Sale, etc., of obscene objects to a young person
•  Imprisonment for 3years or Fine of 2,000 rupees
•  For subsequent conviction imprisonment for 7 years and also with 5,000.

General Issue of Order by Legislation.

There are general cases in which the Supreme Court has been given or issues certain orders and  guidelines and these are as follows:

The Supreme Court of India has refused to block the pornographic websites from internet and also further proceed that watching porn videos at home in private is not a crime (2015).[2]

The Government of India also issues certain orders regarding the Pornographic websites, and block at least 857 websites from Indian ISPs.(2015 August).[3]

The Supreme Court also asked some suggestions from Indian Government certain ways to ban all kinds of child pornography (2016 Feb.).[4]

Even, the Uttarakhand High court has also ordered the Government to block 827 pornographic websites from the Internet, while after the case of a rape victim from Dehradun by her seniors in 2018 Oct, as the all four accused admitted that, they had done this offence after watching porn on the internet.[5]

The following criminal and civil actions shall apply to the foregoing violations:

(a) Criminal sanctions. It shall be a crime to violate this ordinance. Penalties shall be determined by the appropriate legislative bodies.

(b) Civil actions. A civil action is created and treble damages shall be awarded for torts such as assault, battery, and false imprisonment that occur in the production of the film.[6]

Landmark Judgment/Case Laws/ 

• Miller v. Calfornia[7] in 1973-The Supreme Court’s definition of obscenity was set out that; prurient interest; patently offensive depictions of specific sexual acts; and the lack of serious value.[8]
• K.D Ltd. & others Vs st. of karnataka[9] -In this case, the supreme court held that Article 19 didn’t say that, no business will be carried on any exhibiting and publishing and gesture or pornographic material or obscene films etc.
• Kamlesh V vs. U.O.I & others-In this case, the supreme court has been issued a notice, after PIL was filed, on round for ban on pornographic material or videos or websites in India and section 88 of IT Act, 2000 was constituted by Advisory committee, having details with regards to pornographic things on the internet.

Most Recent Cases-

• Ms X vs State & Ors on 26 August 2020– a matter of child pornography and constitutes an offence under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012.
• Amal Roy vs the State Of Kerala on 17 July 2020– Petitioner is the accused in Crime No.980 of 2020 of Ernakulam Central Police Station. The above case is registered against the petitioner alleging offence punishable u/s.67B of Information Technology Act.

Conclusion

It is thus concluded that porno is nothing but it is similar to business marketing of both the gender, as shown for especially for those who are interested to get indulge themselves in sexual or porn acts. Watching and keeping these kinds of pornographic materials is illegal in India. Nowadays, the Government has played a vital role in reducing these acts from websites.

Indians follow the dualism principle, in which they continue the use of cyber pornography. In India, till 2018, Government has banned almost 900 websites regarding Porn.

---

References:

• Information Technology Act, 2000.
• The Indian Constitution.
• Indian Penal Code, 1860.
• Deccan chronicle
• Journals
• Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines) Rules 2011
• India kanoon.com

[1] Porn Hub data

[2]  “It’s legal to watch porn in the privacy of your house, says SC”. Hindustan Times. 9 July 2015. Retrieved 20 December 2016

[3] Deccan Chronicle. 4 August 2015.

[4] Deccan Chronicle. 27 February 2016.

[5] “SC asks Centre to suggest measures to ban child pornography”. Deccan Chronicle. 27 February 2016

[6] Deana Pollard, Regulating Violent Pornography, 43 VAND. L. REV.

125, 155 (1990).

[7] 475 U.S. 1001 (1986)

[8] As the court stated:

[9] (1995) 1 SCC 574